Who would you go for?

1. McKinnon
2. Sharp
3. Martin
4. Yeaman
5. Briscoe

6. Horne
7. Seymour

8. Lynch
9. Houghton
10. Moa

11. Tickle
12. Manu
13. Westerman

14. O'Meley
15. O'Carrol
16. Heremeia/Turner
17. Turner/Whiting/Nicklas

Tickle at LF, Westy out wide IMO.

Turner, Nicklas, Whiting and Aspinwall fighting for the 2 bench spots if Heremia is out.

1. McKinnon
2. Sharp
3. Martin
4. Yeaman
5. Briscoe
6. Horne
7. Seymour
8. Lynch
9. Houghton
10. Moa
11. Tickle
12. Manu
13. Westerman

14. O'Meley
15. O'Carrol
16. Heremaia
17. Aspinwall/Whiting

Agree with your starting 13 although I think Nicklas played his way played his way into the squad and Aspinwall deserves a spot after yesterday.imo.

I think 1-10 pretty much picks itself, it's the back row that needs some fine tuning IMO. If Westerman is struggling with the additional work that comes with playing LF then maybe swap him with Tickle but allow him to play the LF role when we have the ball.

Westerman is a LF, it will take him a few games to get his positional play spot on, just like everyone. It's barmy to suggest putting him back in the 2nd row IMO, after all the crying out for him at LF. I thought he had some nice touches yesterday, but then went missing in attack a little, but those are things that come with game time.

1. McKinnon
2. Sharp
3. Martin
4. Yeaman
5. Briscoe
6. Horne
7. Seymour
8. Lynch
9. Houghton
10. Moa
11. Tickle
12. Manu
13. Westerman

14. O'Meley
15. O'Carrol
16. Heremaia
17. Aspinwall

If Heremaia is fit where does Nicklas fit in to the bench, I don't see a place?

I thought we we're picking on form not reputation and from what I've seen from Danny these 4 preseason games I can't see how you can leave him out. Unless you names Agar.

Agree..But i can't see Nicklas in the 17 unless Heremaia is out.If he is the then i can see DN getting on the bench.

Yeah but if we had 5 wingers in form you would not pick them all would you?

Danny won't play 6/7 ahead of Horne/Seymour and won't play at hooker ahead of Houghton/Heremaia. Not yet anyway. So why would you have him on the bench, it would ruin the balance of the 17.

When in our 147 year history have we had 5 wingers in the kind of form they're all pushing for a first team spot and how would having Danny Nicklas on the bench who can cover the halfback and hooking roles over Heremaia who can cover half back role as well as hooking role ruin the balance.?
All I'm saying is from what I've seen Danny deserves a chance. As the thirty minutes I saw of Heremaia he needed this weekend to really stake a claim but unfortunately through no fault of his own he couldn't and Danny grabbed it with both hands imo.
At the end of the day its PG's call and I will respect whatever he decides.

Pretty certain this will be the team unles Heremaia is injured then i'd imagine Nicklas will take his bench spot.